Friday, June 21, 2024
HomeFoodPurina Pro Plan Vs Purina One Kitten Food

Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina One Kitten Food

What Do Customers Think Of Purina Pro Plan Cat Food

Dog food review: Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan: What is the difference between the brands?

Purina Pro Plan is regarded as one of Purinas highest-quality brands and is well-accepted by most customers.

Most Purina Pro Plan product listings receive high ratings and positive feedback. On Consumer Affairs, the brand receives a mix of negative and positive reviews, with things leaning towards negativity. Most complaints are from people whose cats got sick after eating Purina Pro Plan, though there dont seem to be any clear connections between the illness and the food. One reviewer in 2017 found pieces of plastic in their Purina Pro Plan cat food. Another in 2015 said their bag was crawling with maggots.

Purina One True Instinct High Protein Natural Wet Cat Food In Sauce Or Gravy

Purina ONE True Instinct High Protein, Natural Wet Cat Food in Sauce or Gravy features tuna as its first ingredient, and it also has chicken and liver for added protein. Each can will have at least 35% protein, and it also contains taurine, an important nutrient found only in animal proteins.

Unfortunately, Purina One True Instinct contains meat by-products, and they also seem to change the formula often, which can upset finicky cats.

  • Some cats picked out the bits they liked
  • Some cats wouldnt eat it.

How Should I Feed Dry Cat Food

Most cat parents feed their cats one of two ways:

  • Free Feeding :Following the feeding guidelines on the bag, they leave the recommended amount of dry food out for their cats to graze on throughout the day. If your cats prefers to only eat crunchy kibble, or they only eat little bits at a time, this may be a good feeding routine for them.

  • Meal Feeding : For this method, cat parents feed their cats only at certain times, and discard any leftovers. This feeding routine allows you to incorporate wet food at meals, since it cant be left out.

  • Also Check: Gargamel Smurfs Cat Name

    The Verdict On Purina Pro Plan

    Purina Pro Plan is another tasty range that your feline furkid is bound to go wild for. The quality of the ingredients is high and the nutritional value is excellent. The ratio of protein, fats, and carbohydrates, is balanced, and its great to see real meat topping the ingredient list.

    The Purina Pro Plan LiveClear formula is the shining star across this range and it has the potential to make a huge difference in your life if youre an allergy sufferer.

    If your wallet can justify the big price tag, youll be getting a high-quality product that contains everything your kitty needs to thrive, but having compared it closely to its cheaper sibling, we feel Purina One offers better value for money with roughly the same level of nutrition.

    Nutrition And Digestion Comparison

    Purina Pro Plan Focus Kitten Chicken &  Rice Formula Dry ...

    Purina Pro Plan also has better nutrient values, with a considerable percentage of difference between the two brands. Their pet food also offers higher levels of fiber content. Why is fiber important, you ask?

    Dogs need adequate amounts of fiber in their diet to help with digestion. Fiber will make it easier on the dogs bowels and regularise bowel movements. Additionally, stools will improve. Conversely, a lack of fiber in his diet can cause constipation.

    Read Also: Binx The Cat From Hocus Pocus

    Instinct Dog Food Vs Purina Pro Plan Dog Food

    Dry Dog Food

    Crude Protein Comparison For Dog Food

    Protein is an extremely important part of your dog’s diet. Without sufficient protein, dogs can develop a wide-range of serious health problems.

    According to our average data, Purina Pro Plan typically provides less protein than Instinct. However, this difference is relatively small and doesn’t represent a significant difference between the two brands. In addition, Purina Pro Plan wet dog foods also provide more protein than Instinct wet foods.

    Crude Fat Comparison For Dog Food

    Dietary fats serves a multitude of roles in the proper development and function of our canine companions. Here are some of the benefits :

    • Help produce prostaglandins, which reduce inflammation among other critical functions.
    • Aid in the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins
    • Improve skin and coat health
    • Improve the palatially of your dog’s food

    If you look at the average percentages of crude fat, you’ll notice that Instinct typically guarantees 3.05% more fat. This is a fairly small difference between Instinct and Purina Pro Plan, but still worth mentioning. In addition, Instinct wet dog foods also provide more fat than Purina Pro Plan wet foods.

    Both brands provide roughly the same amount of crude fiber. With regards to wet dog food, Instinct and Purina Pro Plan also provide roughly the same amount of crude fiber.

    Guaranteed Analysis: Purina One Vs Purina Pro Plan

    According to AAFCO, all pet food labels must provide a guaranteed analysis of nutrient content. The analysis must provide guaranteed minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat, and maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture.

    All percentages used in this comparison are averages reported on adry matter basis.

    Don’t Miss: How To Make Microscope In Little Alchemy

    Purina One Vs Pro Plan: Which One Should You Choose

    Both Purina One and Purina Pro Plan are two really popular dog food brands from Purina. Pro Plan is a top-of-the-range line that boasts specialized formulas for weight management, health concerns, and age.

    Purina One, on the other hand, is a more affordable option. Both brands claim to use high-quality, natural ingredients but there are a few key differences when it comes to Purina One vs Pro Plan.

    So, which of these dog food brands is better for you and your dog? Lets have a look!

    Key Features Of The Blue Buffalo Brand

    Dog food review: Purina One vs Purina Beneful
    • Gluten-free and grain-free formula

    Purina Pro Plan pet foods come in four different variants:

    • The Purina Pro Plan Savor This is the brands optimum canine nutrition on a day-to-day basis
    • The Purina Pro Plan Focus this is geared primarily for pooches with unique needs such as those with diabetes, arthritis, etc.
    • The Purina Pro Plan Sport this variant supports the lifestyle of a highly active sporting dog by furnishing them with the required nutrients for strength and endurance.
    • The Pro Plan Bright Mind this is the perfect puppy food plan as it is geared toward optimum development of puppys brains.

    The Purina Pro Plan brand is also unique in the sense that they use high-quality, animal-based proteins in all their formulations or diets along with antioxidant-rich fruits, wholesome carbs, healthy fatty acids, vegetables, etc.

    The Purina Pro Plan brand believes in customizing a dog diet so that they can meet its nutritional requirements at all times. This is why they have become the go-to brand for any kind of balanced nutrition that your canine friend needs.

    You May Like: When It Lands Rainbow Kitten Surprise Lyrics

    Whats Not So Good About Purina

    Theres no denying that Purina tends to have a good reputation and the breadth of choice is impressive. That being said, the quality is not always as good as wed expect from this well-known brand.

    Some of the ingredients are controversial, especially the use of meat and poultry by-products. And instead of using vegetables, such as beetroot, to get a natural coloring, many of Purinas products opt for artificial colors or dyes, which arent a great choice when it comes to health.

    An overuse of soybean, corn, and wheat meal as fillers has also caused us to raise an eyebrow as there are brands on the market these days that are proving that these ingredients are unnecessary.

    If you have a dog with allergies or sensitivities, we recommend you read the ingredient list carefully before purchasing to ensure its suitable for your pup.

    How I Did The Purina One Vs Pro Plan Comparison

    I see brand comparisons in many cases in which differences are described based on a few data by selecting random products.

    Well, I dont think thats satisfactory. We need to compare more products of the two brands for the same purposes and we need to look at as much data as possible.

    These recipes need to be purchased and tested, which I think is very important. It is also worth relying on the opinions of other customers and dog owners.

    So here is my comparison method:

    If you are curious about the detailed comparison, be sure to read on!

    Recommended Reading: Little Alchemy Cheats Animals

    This Food Uses Just As Many Questionable Ingredients As Pro Plan

    Most of their recipes use cheap fillers and animal by-products, same as Pro Plan. However, the latter tends to have more options that allow you to sidestep those questionable foods.

    One of the big selling points of this food is all the probiotics that they added to the recipe. This gives your dog a lot of digestive support, making it a good choice for animals with sensitive stomachs.

    Youll find tender meat pieces mixed in with the dry kibble, and that makes it attractive to most dogs. Thats part of why this line is called SAVOR: its designed to be delicious and nutritious.

    Its full of omega fatty acids, too, thanks to ingredients like fish oil, beef tallow, and fish meal. Thats good for everything from brain development to immune support.

    Unfortunately, theres quite a bit of filler in here, mostly in the form of wheat and corn. Its fairly high in salt, too, so it may not be a good idea for overweight pups.

    FOCUS is the lines skin-enhancement brand, and its designed to keep your dogs coat and skin glowing well into her golden years.

    As a result, its full of fish, as fish has the DHA and EPA needed to keep your pups exterior in fine working condition. That includes real salmon, salmon meal, and fish oil, all of which are sensational for just about every part of your dogs body.

    All in all, though, this is an excellent food for sensitive pups, or any dog that needs a big boost of omegas.

    Iams Proactive Health Mature Adult Dry Dog Food

    Purina Pro Plan True Nature Kitten Chicken &  Egg Recipe ...

    Key features:

    • The first 5 ingredients are Chicken, Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Whole Grain Barley, Ground Whole Grain Corn, Ground Whole Grain Sorghum
    • Formulated to support the nutritional needs of senior dogs
    • Supports bone and joint health
    • Contains antioxidants
    • Includes prebiotics and fibers

    The primary sources of protein are chicken and chicken by-meal. The former is very good quality meat, and the other is a rich source of glucosamine and chondroitin. These are the vitamins for the joints, which is not a negligible fact in the case of elderly dogs.

    Ground Whole Grain Barley, Ground Whole Grain Corn, Ground Whole Grain Sorghum are the recipes carbs. Of these, corn is quite questionable as it causes sensitivity in many dogs. The other carbohydrates are considered adequate.

    There is no separate source of fat in the product. This isnt necessarily a problem, as old dogs dont need a lot of calories. The DHA content is also important for old dogs. Marine Microalgae provides this ingredient.

    And thats not all. The added vitamins and minerals are great for your old dogs immune system. That is, this recipe promises a long and healthy life.


    The decision is not easy now.

    The IAMS product contains less fat and calories. This is very important for old dogs as they are less active, and their metabolism is also reduced. Another benefit of IAMS is Marine Microalgae, which contains a lot of omega 3 fatty acids.

    Overall, Purina won this round.

    4.6 4.6

    Don’t Miss: Sifting Cat Litter

    Guaranteed Analysis: Purina Pro Plan Vs Authority

    According to AAFCO, all pet food labels must provide a guaranteed analysis of nutrient content. The analysis must provide guaranteed minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat, and maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture.

    All percentages used in this comparison are averages reported on adry matter basis.

    Iams Proactive Health High Protein Adult Dry Cat Food

    One problem with many dry cat foods is that they tend to lack protein. But the IAMS High Protein dry cat food contains a minimum of 32% crude protein. The first ingredient listed is chicken, followed by chicken by-product meal, ensuring that the protein in this blend comes from quality animal sources.

    Despite the quality protein sources, there are some ingredients in here were not particularly fond of. Namely, all the corn ingredients, which can be difficult for some cats to digest.But this food does offer many other benefits. For instance, its got fatty acids to improve your cats skin and coat. Vitamin E will boost your cats immune system, and since this blend is formulated to reduce urinary pH, it will help maintain a healthy urinary system.

    • Uses quite a few corn products

    Don’t Miss: Can You Use Pine Pellets For Cat Litter

    Start With The Basics

    Several basic factors will guide your dog food comparison process. These include your dogs breed, age, size and activity levels.

    If you have a large or giant breed dog, his nutritional needs will differ from those of a toy breed.

    Also consider your dogs age and life stage. Puppies need specific nutrients like DHA to help with their development. Around age one , you should transition your puppy to an adult dog food.

    Purina brands offering puppy food formulas include:

    • Beneful
    • Purina ONE
    • Purina Pro Plan

    Purina considers dogs age seven or older senior. If your dog is seven, now is a good time to transition him to a senior-specific dog food. Senior dogs benefit from nutrition focused on healthy aging.

    Purina brands with senior nutrition include:

    • Purina ONE

    Dry Cat Food Drawbacks

    Purina Pro Plan LiveClear – How Our Cat Food Reduces Allergens
  • Studies have shown a correlation between obesity and feeding dry cat food. This could be because a lot of cats that eat dry food are often free-fed, and owners do not realize how much their cats are actually eating in a day.

  • It can also cause the opposite problem because its hard to notice that your cat is not eating when they are free-fed. The amount your cat eats in a day should be monitored or measured out for both reasons.

  • Older cats with dental disease or those who have had some of their teeth removed may also have a harder time chewing dry food.

  • Don’t Miss: How To Check Cats Temperature

    The Were All About Cats Standardrating Purina Pro Plan On What Matters

    Weve analyzed Purina Pro Plan and graded it according to the Were All About Cats standard, evaluating the brand on species-appropriateness, ingredient quality, product variety, price, customer experience, and recall history. Heres how it rates in each of these six key areas.

    • Recall History 5/10

    Overall Score: 5.8/10

    We give Purina Pro Plan cat food a 36 out of 60 rating or a C+ grade.

    Other Controversial Ingredients Used By Purina Pro Plan Include:

    • Vegetable Oil Some vegetable oils are positive ingredients that do a lot of good to our pets bodies. However, it is important to state the particular vegetable that was used in the production of the oil. No specific statements can be made if the vegetable used to create this ingredient remains unknown.

    It is important with any fat source to know certain things such as the omega-3 to omega-3 fatty acid ratio, etc. This property cannot be determined with this particular ingredient from an unknown source. This is the primary reason why vegetable oil got on this list.

    • Garlic Powder Garlic power is good as an additive in pet foods. But they must be present in very small quantities because garlic can be toxic. If you are a cat or a dog owner you are at liberty to avoid any pet food with garlic in them.
    • Poultry Poultry is another controversial ingredient since the source animal is unknown. It is assumed that anonymous animal ingredients are typically low in quality compared to protein sources that are specified such as turkey, chicken, duck, etc.
    • Poultry By-Product Meal Poultry by-product meal has no specified source.
    • Corn Gluten Meal Corn gluten meal is a by-product derived from the production of multiple corn products such as corn syrup, corn starch, etc. Granted, this ingredient has extremely high protein content nearly 60% protein which is believed to have boosted the overall protein content of the product.

    Don’t Miss: What’s The Cats Name On The Smurfs

    Purina Vs Iams Overall Comparison

    Below, I will try to compare the two brands from different perspectives. But of course, I also take into account the reviews so far. Ill write about recall histories, flavors, selection, and other important aspects. We are slowly approaching the end of the article and you will soon know if Purina or IAMS is the better brand.

    Recall History Of Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina One

    PURINA PRO PLAN Prime Plus Adult 7+ Chicken &  Rice Formula ...

    Of the two, Pro Plan is the only one with a recent recall incident, and that was relatively minor.

    In March of 2016, Purina recalled Pro Plan wet foods due to concerns that the food didnt live up to the nutritional value on the label. The food wasnt dangerous, and no dogs were hurt.

    As best we can tell, there havent been any recalls of Purina ONE for at least the past ten years.

    Also Check: Talking Kitty Cat 51


    Most Popular