Our Cat Litter Testing Methodology
I tested the cat litters in two phases: a pre-cat phase and a cat phase. First, I compared litters belonging to the same category in heats of four at a time, assessing them for a variety of factors, including clumping ability, dustiness, scent, and texture.
The top two litters in each heat went on to the next phase. Each one was poured into a litter pan for the cats to use for anywhere from one to four weeks to test for odor control and tracking. Litters that were tested for two weeks or less were those that my cats refused to use or those we tested prior to receiving the bulk of the litters for this guide. For each litter, I considered the following qualities:
You May Like: How Old Should A Kitten Be To Adopt
Why Trust The Spruce
When looking into the best picks to include, we read dozens of product reviews from retailer sites and the Spruce Petsâ contributing reviewers. We also test top products.
This article was originally written by Madeleine Burry, who has covered how to care for pets for more than a decade. Additional research and editing was contributed by Lily Sperry, a lifestyle writer and commerce editor at the Spruce.
Fresh Step Clean Paws Clumping Cat Litter Best Overall
The Fresh Step 32397 Clean Paws Clumping Litter is another clay formula that comes in an 18.5-, 34.2-, or 37-pound bag. This is a low-scent cat litter that is soft on your cats paws, plus it will reduce and eliminate foul-odors from the box. Not only that, but the odor-control lasts for almost a week.
Be advised that the Fresh Step formula does not clump as well as others. Not to mention, it is not as absorbent. Though it is light and easy to change out, you will have to do so more often with this brand. You should also consider that this option has some dust. It can also track through your home.
Beyond that, this is a safe and non-toxic option for keeping your litter box fresh. Made from natural clay material, it will naturally absorb moisture, though as mentioned, it is not as effective as others.
If you need a more affordable option, the Dr. Elseys 460U Clumping Cat Litter is a great option you should try. This is a 99% dust-free formula that is hypoallergenic and safe for all humans and pets. It is also unscented but still provides a fresh fragrance.
As a clay-based litter, the Dr. Elseys product creates hard clumps that make cleaning the litter box a breeze. You will find it to have great odor control and absorption, as well. Whats more, this litter is safe for your children and pets, plus it is non-toxic.
But, to conclude, we think that when it comes to premium choices, you cant beat this best non-tracking cat litter.
Read Also: How To Train A Cat To Behave
What Do Customers Think Of Boxiecat Litter
All three varieties of Boxiecat litter that we reviewed scored very high with customers, with the Gently Scented formula scoring 4/5 stars on Chewy and 4.2/5 stars on Amazon, the Extra Strength Unscented formula scoring 4/5 stars on Chewy and 4.3/5 stars on Amazon, and the Premium Unscented formula scoring 4.2/5 stars on Chewy and 4.2/5 stars on Amazon.
As with all litters, there are both good and bad reviews out there, so you may have to do some experimenting to find out what works best for your cats and what works best for you.
Keep reading to see positive and negative reviews for the varieties of litters featured above:
Here Are The Similarities Between Our Formulas
All our litter products clump like a charm!
- Flat top clumps don’t soak to the bottom and stick
- Leaves your litter box cleaner and better smelling
- Easier to scoop
All our litter products do an outstanding job with odor control!
- No ammonia odors
All our litter products have ultra-low dust!
- No dust clouds when you pour
- Healthy and good for cat and human allergies
- No dust accumulating in your home
See the features of each formula below – click on the header links to learn more about each
Don’t Miss: Why Do Cats Move Their Water Bowl
Paws Happy Life Vs Boxiecat Cat Litter Review
A few years ago, we switched to Boxiecat litter after a coworker recommended it. Its a very low dust clay clumping litter, which I like because Taco has chronic sinus issues.
When I needed fresh cat litter in a hurry for a rescued cat in the playpen, I got the cheapest clumping litter at the local grocery store close to my house, Paws Happy Life litter.
I was surprised by how well the Paws Happy Life worked, given the low cost.
If you want to see both litters in action , you can watch the video review.
Below the video, I will discuss the pros and cons of both litters. All comments are based on my experiences of scooping both brands of litter not just summarizing other peoples reviews on store websites.
Introducing: Boxiepro Deep Clean Probiotic Cat Litter
I like to think we are pretty on top of what is new and innovative in the world of cat products, but we somehow missed when BoxiePro Deep Clean Probiotic Cat Litter was first released. Thankfully they offered to send me a bag to review and put their new product to the test.
Why would you need probiotics in a cat litter?
In third party lab tests, BoxiePro probiotics eliminated 100% of bacteria in the litter box. By wiping out harmful bacteria and odors in the litter box, BoxiePro keeps your cat and home cleaner and healthier. Because BoxiePro stays so clean and forms smaller and lighter clumps, it is also longer-lasting, which is important to remember because this litter isnt exactly cheap. I just went a week, and with regular scooping, I only had to add a tiny bit of additional litter. Also, I put a thin layer of BoxiePro in our other litterboxes to help deodorize them. I still have over half our original bag of litter left. This litter may be more expensive, but it does last a lot longer than other clumping litters.
Nobody likes the smell of the litter box wafting through their home. The probiotics seem to be doing a great job of keeping the odors at bay. As for tracking, the BoxiePro is the same as other litters we have used. We have a bunch of litter mats that catch the litter so it never really gets tracked outside of the room we have the litterboxes in.
Oliver puts the BoxiePro Litter to the test
Oliver checking out the bag of BoxiePro
What is Flat Top Litter?
Read Also: How Do You Get Cat Scratch Fever
Advantages Of Buying Products With Low Price
Buying products at a low price is never a bad idea, but you should know the advantages.
- First, when buying bulk or shopping online, you can save more money because they do not charge shipping for each item.
- Second, purchasing items at lower prices means having more room in your budget for other things.
- Thirdly, if an items quality is just as good, then theres no need to spend extra on higher-priced items!
- Fourthly, by purchasing cheaper goods less often, people can save up their money to invest it in something else!
- Lastly, buying more affordable products helps the environment by decreasing the number of materials used and wasted.
Litter Everywhere Get The Best Non Tracking Cat Litter For Finicky Cats
Here are the best non tracking cat litter well be covering:
- Clay litter option: Dr. Elseys Premium Clumping Cat Litter
Keeping the area around the litter box clean is essential. Some cats kick litter all over the place and it ends up tracking throughout your house. Its difficult to maintain a tidy litter box area unless you know how to prevent it from happening. Keep reading to learn why cats fling litter around, and what you can do about it.
It might not feel like it, but your cat isnt kicking litter out of the box on purpose. They instinctively dig in the litter to create a shallow well to do their business in.
Once they are done, cats are compelled to cover it up. There is a logical reason for this. In the wild, cats cover up their waste to keep predators or competitors from knowing where they are. This keeps them and their kittens safe.
So how do you keep cats from flinging their litter? You have several options to choose from.
- The brand of litter you fill it with might be too sticky. Cats are very finicky about cleanliness. If litter sticks to their paws, they will do whatever they can to get the granules off them. Switching to a low-tracking litter will help.
- You know your cat is going to kick litter around. To prevent it from flying all over the room, consider getting a litter box with higher walls. As a last resort, try using an enclosed litter box with the best non tracking cat litter.
Recommended Reading: What Do You Need For A New Kitten
Recommended Reading: How To Prevent Cat Allergies In Adults
How Much Is Pretty Litter
A single 4 lbs. bag of Pretty Litter costs $22 and should last a single cat for 1 month. You can purchase additional bags at a discount of $2 per bag. Two bags of Pretty Litter will cost $40 and three bags will cost $60. All orders come with free shipping and you can customize your delivery schedule.
Buying Guide To Choose The Best Clay Clumping Litter For Litter Robot
Product quality is usually a priority for consumers, but it can also be costly. Many people are faced with buying a more expensive product that they feel will last longer or with something cheaper that may not provide as much value.
The next time you consider buying the clay clumping litter for litter robot, consider your priorities and whether this particular product will meet those needs.
- Are you looking for something high-quality?
- Do you need it now?
- Will this purchase help make room in your budget for other things later down the road?
These are all questions worth asking yourself before making any big decisions.
Recommended Reading: Can Cats Be Trained Like Dogs
Arm & Hammer Easy Clean
Our next option uses the power of baking soda to eliminate odors in your litter box. The Arm & Hammer 20505679 Easy Clean-Up Clumping Litter is a clay-based formula that will keep smells from urine, feces, and other organic materials at bay.
Available in a 37-pound bag, the Arm & Hammer litter creates tight clumps. It is very absorbent, and it will not dry on the sides of your cat box. Whats more, this non-tracking cat litter has a fresh light scent, plus it is safe for your cats paw pads. Be advised, however, that it is not as good at not sticking to the bottom of your pets feet and it gets stuck in between their toes.
Other than that, this litter is soft against your furballs paws, so they will not get any scratches or nicks. Keep in mind though, there is more dust kick-back with this option. Also, it can be heavy when wet.
The Purina 12118666 Tidy Cats Non-Clumping Cat Litter is available in a 10-, 20-, or 30-pound bag. This is a non-clumping formula that is designed to slide right off the pan when it is time to clean. It is recommended that you clean solid waste daily with this type, so it is not always the most popular choice.
That being said, you will not find a lot of tracking with this clay litter. The Purina is designed for multi-cat homes, yet unfortunately, the odor control and absorption leaves a lot to be desired. Not only that, but this litter is heavy when saturated, so those who cannot lift heavy items would not be happy with this product.
Boxiecat Extra Strength Premium Clumping Clay Cat Litter
Are you looking for the best non-tracking cat litter that your cat would love? Then you should consider the Boxiecat Extra Strength Premium Clumping Clay Cat Litter. This firm only uses high quality, all-natural premium clay. It does not add any dyes, fragrances, or chemicals. This product is also cat-friendly, as it is made with soft and fine granules that are easy on the paws of your cat. It also does a great job of being resistant to tracking outside of the litter box.
In addition to being one of the best non-tracking cat litters, this product is 99 percent dust-free to avoid triggering allergic reactions no sniffles and no sneezing for you! It also means that your air and home would not be contaminated with dust whenever your cat uses the litter box. With this litter, scooping is made easier, as it clumps your cats waste quickly and hardly. You do not need to go through the hassle of searching for the mess, as it would just be right on top of the litter.
It also features a natural and safe probiotic odor control that stops bad smells before they start. With this feature, you might not even remember that you have a litter box right in your room. It also boasts of lasting two times longer than many cat litters out there. It practically feels like new after several cleanings. This product is also ideal for multiple cats, as well as cats on a high protein diet. Veterinarians also recommend it.
Also Check: Do Cats Bleed Before Giving Birth
Best Overall Cat Litter
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Boxiecat Extra Strength Scent
- Recommended by Veterinarians — Ranked #1 in Odor Control in Veterinary Professional Study
- Probiotics Prevent Odors from Forming — For a Fresher, Cleaner Smelling Home
- Multiple Cat Formula
- Ultra Low Dust — 99.9% Dust-Free — Hypo-Allergenic
- Longer Lasting — Use Less, Save More
- No Sticking or Breaking Apart — Instant Flat Top Clump Forms on Top of the Box — Easy to Scoop and Clean the Litter Box
Don’t Miss: How To Cut Cat Nails With Human Clippers
How To Stop Cat Litter Tracking
In some ways cat litter tracking is just one of those little inconveniences that cat parents have to put up with. But there are still options and strategies we can use to keep the mess to a minimum.
To this end weve reviewed the best non tracking cat litters on the market. As well as optional accessories you may find helpful in answering the exasperating conundrum of how to keep cat litter off the floor.
Recommended Reading: Can Cats Eat Raw Egg Yolk
Negative Customer Reviews For Pretty Litter Cat Litter
So, it doesnt smell like cat urine, but it doesnt cover up the poop smell. And my cat has managed to get it everywhere just like regular litter. I do like that theres less scoping and its lighter, but Im not sure Im going to continue after Im through with what I bought. Becca K.
I only have 1 cat and clean it out daily and move it around after each visit. Ive only had the first bag in for 2 weeks and it is really starting to smell. I am going to have to change it. I wont be able to get a month use out of 1 bag which is disappointing due to the price. Vicky G.
You May Like: When Can Kittens Be Weaned
Free Shipping On All Us Orders Of This Product
Veterinarian recommended and winner of the Cat Fancy Editors Choice Award, Boxiecat litter quality makes a noticeable difference.
Unlike other scented litters, Boxiecat Gently Scented is not just pleasing to humans, but is also cat friendly. Veterinarian-developed, its scent is safe and preferred by cats, and has natural ingredients that are calming for cats. Its called Boxiecat Calm and is moisture activated. Its an alternative to other scented litter products which can be overpowering for cats sensitive sense of smell.
Purina Tidy Cats Breeze Litter System Refills
The Purina Tidy Cats Breeze Litter System Refills is in the market to completely prevent your little felines from having litter sticking into their paws. The pellets of this litter are made with an anti-tracking formula that keeps cat waste from scattering all over the house. This litter guarantees the lowest tracking as it dehydrates the solid waste of your cat. This product can also keep any moist debris from sticking into the paws of your furry felines.
With this product, you do not have to worry about cleaning extra dust from litter pellets, as it is also 99.99 percent dust-free. It does not contain clay or silica dust. This means that you and your little friend would be safe from allergic reactions that are triggered by dust. This low-tracking cat litter comprises silica gel, zeolite, and a moisture-repellent polymer coating. Cats find this litter very comforting, thanks to its anti-moisture feature.
This product also comes with a technology that separates liquid from solids for outstanding odor control. The pellets let liquid waste to go through the absorbent pad for odor control. This feature leaves your litter box with a fresh smell for up to a week. This litter also makes it very easy to scoop, as it keeps the solid waste on top pellets. The drawback of this unit is that it is non-biodegradable. This means you cannot compost it. As a result of this, you cannot flush this litter into the toilet.
Donât Miss: Tuna And Egg Cat Food
Also Check: How To Get Rid Of Cat Food Smell